17 BEST Hotels In Caye Caulker For Every Traveler In 2025
Planning a trip to Caye Caulker and looking for the perfect place to stay?
You’re in the right spot! I’ve got you covered with the best Caye Caulker hotels.
After visiting this small island in Central America four years in a row, I’ve gotten to know the island inside and out – and I’ve stayed in a bunch of different hotels. So, trust me, I’ve rounded up the top stays with options for every budget.
In this guide, you’ll find the best accommodation options on both sides of the split – so you can have and amazing stay on Caye Caulker.
Fun fact: This island was actually split in two by a Hurricane, creating “The Split,” where there’s a north and south part of Caye Caulker. I’ll cover which side is the best to stay on.
Short on Time? Choose My Favorite Hotel on Cay Caulker!
El Ben Cabana’s – cutest cabanas, quiet, romantic, great restaurant!
17 Best Hotels In Caye Caulker
No matter your budget, Caye Caulker has the perfect spot for you – whether you’re looking to be close to the island’s nightlife or right on the water in a beachside cabana. You’ll find just the right place to make your stay unforgettable.
And if you’re planning to explore beyond the island of Caye Caulker, I’ve got you covered with a guide to the best places to stay in Belize!
My Top Three Hotel Picks In Caye Caulker
I’m going to start out with my favorite three places to stay in Caye Caulker, from luxury to budget. Then I’ll give you more choices for you to make your own decisions based on your preferences.
1. El Ben Cabañas
El Ben Cabana’s is my favorite place to stay on the island and thats why I’ve included it in my Caye Caulker Travel Guide.
It is the most welcoming and romantic spot that I have stayed at on Caye Caulker. It feels like a tropical paradise within paradise. I particularly love the thatched roof cabanas!
Location: North Island
AMENITIES:
Pool
Air conditioning
Caribbean Sea view
Bech Bar
On site restaurant
Bicycle rental
SPECIAL TOUCHES:
Cabanas with thatched roofs
Private verandas
Romantic
Quiet
2. Jan’s Hotel
Jan’s Hotel is a popular hotel in Caye Caulker and it’s in such a great location!
Just a few steps away from one of Caye Caulker’s best beach areas and within walking distance to all the restaurants, shops, and the iconic Split. And my favorite part is its right across the street from my favorite dive shop!
You’ll feel welcomed like family at Jan’s Hotel.
I stayed here twice, and I can’t recommend them enough! Be sure to book one of the rooms with a balcony and ocean view for sunrise coffees!
Location: South Island, Center of Town
AMENITIES:
SPECIAL TOUCHES:
- Swimming Pool
- Air conditioning
- Kids stay free
- Ocean view
- Kitchenette
- Near the “Split”
- Private balcony
3. Barefoot Caye Caulker Hotel
One of the best options for affordable luxury, Barefoot Caye Caulker Hotel offers rooms, suites, cabanas, studios, and huts. Personally, I love cabanas!
Plus, the sunning deck with hammocks and tiki umbrellas adds a cool, laid-back touch – perfect for a true island experience.
Location: South Island/Center of Town on Main Street
AMENITIES:
SPECIAL TOUCHES:
- Air conditioning
- Private beach
- Bar/Lounge
- Swimming Pool/Poolside Bar
- Free Bike rentals
- Sunning deck
- Rooftop Terrace
- Tiki umbrellas
Best Luxury Hotels in Caye Caulker
Of course, if you want to stay in a luxurious hotel, Caye Caulker has a few options.
Here are the top luxury places to stay on Caye Caulker:
4. Treetops Hotel
The views here are insane!
This boutique hotel is close to everything but just far enough away to let you hear the waves and the wind rustling through the palms.
It’s perfect for honeymooners looking for romance or families too.
You’re gonna fall in love with Treetops Hotel and never want to leave – they treat you like absolute royalty.
Location: South Island
AMENITIES:
SPECIAL TOUCHES:
- Air conditioning
- Private beach
- Bar/Lounge
- Complimentary bicycles
- Laundry Facilities
- Ocean view
- Family friendly
5. BluZen
These luxury Caye Caulker condos, surrounded by white sandy beaches and beautiful property, are a mix of “off the grid” but close enough to the Split and all the action.
Enjoy these air-conditioned, immaculate suites at reasonable rates.
Location: North Island
AMENITIES:
SPECIAL TOUCHES:
- Air conditioning
- Private beach
- Multiple swimming pools
- Bar/Lounge
- Fitness gym
- Bicycles
- Full-service spa
- Water taxi for guests from the resort to the Split
- Quiet secluded luxury
Best Mid-Range Hotels on Caye Caulker
Belize has a variety of mid-range hotels that offer great comfort and amenities without breaking the bank.
Here are the best mid-range hotels on Caye Caulker:
6. Island Magic Beach Resort
The Island Magic Villas are pure island bliss – it’s got all the chill vibes you’re dreaming of.
Perfect for relaxing, a romantic escape, or even a fun family getaway, it really has a little something for everyone. The rooms are clean and spacious, and the views from your private balcony?
Absolutely breathtaking.
Location: South Island
AMENITIES:
SPECIAL TOUCHES:
- Air conditioning
- Ocean view
- Spa/ Pool with swim-up bar
- Kitchenette
- Bar/Lounge
- Private balcony
- Centrally located
- Transportation provided
7. The Bounty Boutique Bohemian Hotel
You will love this hotel’s Bohemian vibe and prime location near restaurants, supermarkets, and local shops.
Choose from oceanfront view apartments, suites, and cabanas to soak up stunning seaside views daily. Whether you’re lounging by the water or exploring the local scene, the Bounty Boutique Bohemian Hotel is a great choice!
Location: South Island / Center of Town
AMENITIES:
SPECIAL TOUCHES:
- Air conditioning
- Ocean view
- Private balcony
- Kitchenette
- Clean, comfortable rooms
- Bohemian interior design
- Adults only!
8. Bay Towers Hotel
The Bay Towers Hotel is a perfect little slice of paradise.
Although it is isolated away from the hustle and bustle of the city, there are no issues getting back and forth from the Split and all the action.
The rooms are clean and spacious, and the balconies give you a bird’s eye view of the gorgeous sunrises/sunsets and the Barrier Reef.
Location: North Island
AMENITIES:
SPECIAL TOUCHES:
- Air conditioning
- Swimming Pool
- Private beach
- Free bikes
- Clean, quiet rooms
- Panoramic views
- Pet friendly
Best Budget Hotels in Caye Caulker
No need to break the bank – I got you! There are plenty of hotels here that’ll suit your style and keep your pocketbook happy.
9. La Isla Resort
You won’t go wrong with the centrally located beachside La Isla resort!
The prices are super reasonable, and you’re just a quick 3-minute walk from the water taxi. Kick back on the sun terrace and soak in those stunning ocean views.
Location: South Island
AMENITIES:
SPECIAL TOUCHES:
- Swimming Pool
- Air conditioning
- Beach/private dock
- Bar/Lounge
- Clean, comfortable private rooms.
- Yoga in the morning
- Free kayaks and paddleboards
10. Rainbow Hotel
Comfortable, affordable, and clean – this lovely hotel offers great value for your money, plus it is centrally located to all the popular spots.
The owner, Ernie, goes above and beyond to ensure your stay is great.
Rainbow Hotel is a winner in the budget category!!
Location: South Island / Center of Town
AMENITIES:
SPECIAL TOUCHES:
- Air conditioning
- Ocean view
- Kitchenette
- Lounge
- Clean, comfortable rooms
- Centrally located
- Family-owned gem
11. Yocamatsu
This eclectic bread and breakfast’s name, Yocamatsu, is derived from “you can’t make this sh*# up.”
I highly recommend this cozy and comfortable hotel with ocean views and private patios. It’s absolutely great for families and even has children’s activities.
TIP: Feed the rays at dusk – a two-minute walk from your hotel.
Location: South Island
AMENITIES:
SPECIAL TOUCHES:
- Ocean view
- Free hot breakfast
- Rooftop terrace
- Air conditioning
- Clean, comfortable rooms
- Children’s activities/ Family friendly
- Ray feeding at dusk
Best Caye Caulker Vacation Rentals
For such a tiny island, Caye Caulker actually has more vacation rentals than hotels – so your perfect stay might just be in one of these unique spots!
I’ve rounded up some of the best rentals that’ll make the ideal base for your beach escape.
12. Lauras Lookout Oceanfront
This vacation rental is perfect for a family of five or a group of friends.
The rooms are comfy and well-equipped, making it a true home away from home. Plus, you’re just a short 10-15 minute walk from other restaurants and activities.
My family and I stayed here to celebrate my 40th birthday, and it was an unforgettable spot – one I’d pick again in a heartbeat!
Location: South Island
AMENITIES:
SPECIAL TOUCHES:
- 2-3 bedrooms
- Kid friendly
- Full Kitchen
- Private beach area and dock
- Bike Rentals
- BBQ Pits
- Stunning ocean views
- Weezie’s Ocean Front Hotel Restaurant on-site
- Accommodates 7 guests
- Walking distance to Caye Caulker airport
13. Panoramic loft with scenic balcony
You will love this one-of-a-kind third-floor studio loft with unobstructed sunrise and sunset views and sights of the Barrier Reef. It’s also just a short walk from the iconic Lazy Lizard.
Located on the north side of the Split, a quick water taxi ride to the loft adds to the adventure.
The loft is fresh and new, and the friendly staff make it a perfect home base for you.
Location: North Island
AMENITIES:
SPECIAL TOUCHES:
- 1 bedroom/2 guests
- 1 bathroom
- Kid friendly
- Kitchenette
- Shared pool/canoes/bikes/grilling area
- Stunning ocean views
- Panoramic unobstructed views
14. Velento Oceanfront Penthouse’s
These penthouses are hands down one of the nicest spots on Caye Caulker – perfect for big family get-togethers or large groups.
You’ll feel right at home with a fully stocked kitchen, family room, dining area, and even a washer and dryer.
The best part? Sliding glass doors bring the Caribbean right into your living space!
Location: North Island
AMENITIES:
SPECIAL TOUCHES:
- 3 bedrooms/ 3 baths
- Kid friendly
- Private dock/pool
- Shared pool/canoes/bikes/grilling area
- Air conditioning
- Million-dollar views
- Open plan kitchen/dining area
- Accommodates 8 guests
15. Seahorse Cabana
The Seahorse Cabana is a great escape if you’re looking to get away from the bustling nightlife. While it’s a bit off the beaten path, a bike or golf cart will make getting around the island a breeze.
It’s right by the airstrip, but you’ll hardly notice any noise. Plus, you get free kayaks and canoes to explore the water!
Location: South Island
AMENITIES:
SPECIAL TOUCHES:
- 1 bedroom / 1 bath
- Kid friendly
- Shared pool
- Air conditioning
- Free kayaks and canoes
- Accommodates 4 guests
16. Coral Cottage
The Coral Cottages are just minutes from town and make an ideal home base for a small family.
They are also very popular with divers. These 850-square-foot, cabin-like cottages have a cozy bedroom plus a loft, comfortably fitting up to four guests.
Don’t miss out on this unique spot for your stay!
Location: South Island
AMENITIES:
SPECIAL TOUCHES:
- 1 bedroom + 1 loft
- 1 bathroom
- Kid-friendly
- Shared pool & patio
- Air conditioning
- Fully equipped kitchen
- Accommodates 4 guests
17. Hidden Gem Cabana
This lovely 800-square-foot apartment comfortably fits five guests and comes with a charming veranda that’s perfect for relaxing.
Only an 8-minute walk to Caye Caulker Beach and tons of great restaurants, the Hidden Gem Cabana is a fantastic value for your money – and the staff are beyond accommodating!
Location: South Island
AMENITIES:
SPECIAL TOUCHES:
- two bedroom / one bath
- Kid-friendly
- Pool and picnic area
- Air conditioning
- Fully equipped kitchen
- Accommodates 5 guests
- Lovely veranda
Best Time To Visit Caye Caulker
Just keep in mind that Caye Caulker really has only two seasons: the wet season and the dry season.
So, the dry season would be the best time to visit, as some of your adventures might get rained out during the wet season.
Belize’s dry season is from late November to May.
This period offers sunny, clear days perfect for all the outdoor and water activities and exploring the island. But, the downside is that it is the peak season for most visitors, and things may be a bit pricier.
Visiting Caye Caulker during the dry season is also the best because it coincides with several vibrant cultural events and seafood seasons. Making it the ideal time for you to experience the island’s full charm.
More Information on Caye Caulker & Belize
BELIZE TRAVEL TIPS: If it’s your first time visiting Belize, don’t miss my 21 Must-Know Belize Travel Tips you need to know before you go. And if you are wondering what to pack for your adventure, you’ll want to check out my Ultimate Belize Packing List next – complete with a Free Printable Checklist!
GETTING AROUND: Need to know how to get to the islands? Check out my guide on How to Easily Get From Belize City to San Pedro and Caye Caulker for all your transport options.
CAYE CAULKER: For a complete look at the island, including the best places to eat, stay, and explore, take a look at my Caye Caulker Travel Guide. If you’re wondering, is Caye Caulker safe? – I’ve broken down everything you need to know about safety on the island. And for all the top activities, don’t miss these 23 UnBelizeable Things To Do In Caye Caulker to make the most of your time on this beautiful island.
FAQs
Got more questions about your stay in Caye Caulker? I’ve got answers to help you plan the perfect trip!
Here’s a quick rundown of the most common questions to make your stay easy and stress-free.
Is Caye Caulker Belize expensive?
Caye Caulker can be as budget-friendly or as luxurious as you make it.
There are options for every type of traveler, from economical hostels and street food to upscale hotels and fine dining.
Generally, it’s considered more expensive than many other Caribbean and Central American destinations.
Is Caye Caulker a party island?
If you’re after a high-energy party scene, Caye Caulker isn’t your spot – that’s more San Pedro’s style.
But Caye Caulker still has its own laid-back nightlife with beach bars, live music, and sunset parties perfect for chilling with the island crowd.
If you’re trying to decide between islands, check out my post on Caye Caulker vs Ambergris Caye to see which one’s the perfect fit for you.
Can you walk around Caye Caulker?
Yes, there are no cars on the island, so walking is the simplest way to get around. You can also rent a bike or a golf cart.
That’s a Wrap on The Best Caye Caulker Hotels
Now that you’ve got all my insider tips on the best Caye Caulker hotels and vacation rentals, it’s time to dust off your suitcase and book that island escape!
I’m positive if you choose one of my top recommendations, you’ll have an unforgettable vacation.