Caye Caulker Vs Ambergris Caye: Which Island Should You Visit?

Welcome to the ultimate showdown between Belize’s two most popular islands: Caye Caulker vs Ambergris Caye.

They may only be separated by 15 miles of stunning turquoise waters, but they couldn’t be more different in spirit and style. Caye Caulker offers a laid-back, barefoot vibe, while Ambergris Caye buzzes with vibrant energy and a bit more polish.

I’ve visited both islands multiple times over the last four years (I can’t seem to stay away) and gotten to know them really well.

In this blog, I’ll break down the unique aspects of each island to help you figure out which one is the best fit for you.

And I’ll tell you which of the two is my favorite!

Colorful mural on Caye Caulker featuring a sea turtle, octopus, and diver, showcasing Caye Caulker vs Ambergris Caye island's vibrant underwater life and artistic vibe. — Caye Caulker vs Ambergris Caye: Helping you choose which one to visit!

A large 'San Pedro' sign with colorful letters stands on a sandy beach, flanked by palm trees. Kate from Kate's Crossing Blog and her husband pose in front of the sign with the ocean and a clear blue sky in the background. — San Pedro sign on Ambergris Caye

TLDR:

Choose Caye Caulker If:

You are traveling on a budget!
You are looking for a tiny paradise.
You like to hang with a younger crowd.
You want to “Go slow,” or you should “go slow” more often!
You want a more authentic feel for the local Caribbean life.

Choose Ambergris Caye If:

You are looking to stay in a beautiful resort.
You want to have more options available.
You want to have a fancy dinner.
You want more of a lively nightlife.
You want to lie on a real beach.

For more detailed tips and insider secrets about traveling in Belize, check out our Ultimate Belize Travel Guide: With the Best Tips and Secrets. It’s packed with valuable information to help you plan your perfect trip.

Which Island Should You Choose? Caye Caulker vs Ambergris Caye

Stuck on choosing between Caye Caulker and Ambergris Caye for your trip to Belize? No worries! To hopefully help you decide, I’ll compare the most important factors of each, side by side.

Let’s break it down and see which one will be your match.

Overview of Caye Caulker

Caye Caulker is the smallest of the two islands, but don’t let its size fool you. It might be tiny, but it packs a punch.

This five-mile-long island in the Caribbean Sea is all about simplicity and oozes rustic island charm.

As the closest island to Belize City, it’s especially accessible and attracts backpackers and a younger crowd.

With only one main town split between the north and south, Caye Caulker is easy to explore on foot or by bike. You won’t find any cars on this island, just the occasional golf cart.

It’s so small that you can stand on Main Street and see the Caribbean Sea to your left and to your right, giving you a real sense of just how small the island really is.

The famous “Split”—a narrow channel of water that divides the island—is not just a geographical feature but a social hub. It’s a popular spot to chill, swim, and meet locals and other travelers over a cold bevi at the Lazy Lizard.

Whether you’re soaking up the sun, sipping on a cold drink, or just enjoying the slow pace of small island life, Caye Caulker offers an authentic slice of paradise where you can truly “go slow.”

A street in Ambergris Caye, Belize, lined with colorful buildings and parked golf carts. Signs advertise local businesses, including a grocery store. People walk and drive golf carts along the road. — Streets of San Pedro Town on Ambergris Caye

Overview of Ambergris Caye

Ambergris Caye is the largest island in Belize, stretching 26 miles long. Centered around the bustling town of San Pedro, this island is a true hub of activity.

Think of Ambergris Caye as the extroverted sibling with more shops, restaurants, and nightlife than its quieter counterpart. It’s the perfect place if you’re looking for a slice of paradise equipped with all the modern comforts.

Given its size, you won’t be able to cover Ambergris Caye on foot—you’ll definitely need some wheels to fully explore. Golf carts (and I mean a LOT of golf carts!) are the most popular choice among visitors wanting to discover every corner of the island.

FYI, you will be sharing the “free for all” roads with scooters, cars, and trucks, so be careful.

And while it may be the furthest from Belize City, Ambergris Caye remains easily accessible, ensuring that its vibrant energy and picturesque beaches are never too far away.

Comparing the Vibes

Caye Caulker and Ambergris Caye each have their own special feel. Here’s a look at what makes the atmosphere of these two Belizean islands different.

Kate sitting on a swing at a beachside bar in Caye Caulker, Belize, wearing a 'Go Slow' tank top and holding a tropical drink. The turquoise ocean and colorful bar decor create a relaxing atmosphere. — Caye Caulkers moto is “Go Slow.”

Caye Caulker’s Vibe

The vibe of Caye Caulker is as laid-back as it gets. Its “Go Slow” motto isn’t just a slogan. It’s a way of life here.

Think slow-paced days, chilling in hammocks, beach bars with sandy floors, and friendly chats with locals.

Honestly, I feel Caye Caulkers’ vibe is more authentic and a bit untouched compared to its sister island, Ambergris Caye. It embraces its rustic roots and offers a slice of island life that feels genuine.

Nightlife here is more about enjoying a sunset with a cool drink rather than partying the night away. There are a few lively bars, but don’t expect the vibrant nightlife you’ll find in San Pedro.

Key Point: If you are looking for a peaceful retreat to unwind and enjoy a slower pace of life, then stay on Caye Caulker.

Kate and her husband dining at a table set in shallow ocean water in Ambergris Caye, Belize. Both are in swimwear and sunglasses, enjoying a seafood meal with the turquoise sea stretching out behind them. — Enjoying dinner at a beach club on Secret Beach

Ambergris Caye’s Vibe

On the flip side, Ambergris Caye pulses with a distinctly more upbeat energy.

Here, life moves at a fast pace, especially in San Pedro Town. The island is often buzzing with the hum of golf carts zipping down the streets.

It’s a lively mix of beach relaxation during the day and a bustling nightlife once the sun goes down.

Whether it’s enjoying live music, hopping from one beach bar to the next, or indulging in some late-night dancing, Ambergris Caye offers a vibrant scene.

Key Point: If you are looking for an energetic vacation with a mix of beach relaxation and vibrant nightlife, then stay on Ambergris Caye.

Comparing the Weather

Both Ambergris Caye and Caye Caulker are blessed with the warm, tropical weather that the Caribbean is famous for.

Both islands maintain average temperatures in the mid-70s to high 80s throughout the year. And even if it rains or the wind picks up, they are both warm, which is still easy to enjoy.

It’s good to know that there is a distinct dry and rainy season. For a deeper dive into what to expect weather-wise and to find out the best times to visit, head over to my other blog post, “Best Time to Visit Belize.”

Activities and Things to Do

Caye Caulker and Ambergris Caye offer a range of activities and things to do. Here’s a look at what you can enjoy on each island.

Kate snorkeling off Caye Caulker, Belize, swimming underwater alongside a large sea turtle. She is wearing a snorkel and fins, exploring the clear turquoise waters. — Snorkeling off Caye Caulker at the Hol Chan Marine Reserve

Things to do on Caye Caulker

Here are the best and my favorite things to do on Caye Caulker;

Relax in a beach hammock and do nothing
Enjoy a day at the Split
Take a snorkeling tour to Hol Chan Marine reserve
Feed the sting rays and look for sea horses at Iguana Reef Beach.
Feed the giant Tarpons
Go scuba diving
Take a sunset boat cruise

Key Point: If you’re looking for a more laid-back adventure and things you can easily walk to, then Caye Caulker is for you.

Kate on a boat in Caye Caulker, Belize, holding a large fish she caught. She is smiling, wearing sunglasses and a cap, with the clear blue ocean in the background. — Reef Fishing off Ambergris Caye

Things to do on Ambergris Caye

Here are some of the top things to do on Ambergris Caye;

You can also take snorkeling tours to Hol Chan Marine Reserve from this island
Rent a golf cart and explore the island
Spend a day swimming and relaxing at Secret Beach
Take a day trip to Caye Caulker
Go reef fishing and have a beach BBQ
Go Scuba Diving
Take a flight tour over the famous Blue Hole

Key Point: If you are seeking a bit more of a thrill and want to explore a bigger island, then Ambergris Caye is for you.

Honestly, both islands serve up incredible experiences! But if you’re wondering what all Belize has to offer, be sure to check out my other blog post, “Best Things to Do in Belize“.

Bicycles parked outside a small beachside bar called Pelican Sunset Bar in Caye Caulker, Belize. A man stands with arms outstretched near the water, surrounded by palm trees and outdoor seating. — Bikes are the best way to get around Caye Caulker

Accessibility and Getting Around On The Islands

Both Caye Caulker and Ambergris Caye are easily accessible from Belize City. You can easily get to both islands by either a water taxi or a short domestic flight with Tropic Air or Maya Air.

For more details and a step-by-step guide on getting from Belize City to the islands, check out my blog post, “How to Easily Get From Belize City to San Pedro and Caye Caulker“

Getting around Caye Caulker

On Caye Caulker, the simplest way to get around is on your own two feet or by bike. This smaller island is so compact that you can walk to almost everything in 10 minutes or less.

There are golf carts available to rent, but you honestly don’t need one.

For those staying on the north side of the split, there’s a handy split ferry available to shuttle you across the channel.

Additionally, many accommodations offer a water taxi service that can zip you back and forth as needed, making it super convenient to navigate the small island.

A teal-colored golf cart parked under trees in Ambergris Caye, Belize. The cart has a windshield and cushioned seats. — Renting a golf cart is a must on Ambergris Caye!

Getting around Ambergris Caye

In contrast, the primary way for tourists to explore Ambergris Caye is by renting a golf cart.

Public transportation is non-existent here—no buses and definitely no rental cars.

Taxis are available, but they’re just golf carts too. Renting your own golf cart will be a lot more fun and it’ll save you money instead of paying for a taxi.

If you stay confined to San Pedro town, you’ll find that it’s quite walkable, and you can easily get to most places on foot.

Types of accommodation

Whether you prefer luxury resorts or cozy guesthouses, Caye Caulker and Ambergris Caye have a variety of accommodations to suit your needs. Here’s an overview of where you can stay on each island.

A charming thatched-roof cabin at El Ben Cabanas on Caye Caulker, Belize. The cabin is surrounded by lush tropical plants and trees, with a wooden staircase leading to the entrance. — El Ben Cabanas on Caye Caulker

Caye Caulker Accommodations

On Caye Caulker, the accommodation scene is charmingly low-key.

You won’t find any fancy resorts or big hotels here, but you will find an array of cozy boutique hotels, hostels, and a few guest houses. Most of these options are on the south side of the split, where all the activity is and closer to many of the island’s main attractions.

However, the north side of the island is building up, offering beautiful beach bungalows and waterside villas that provide a more secluded and upscale island experience.

🏨 My favorite place I stayed at on Caye Caulker was El Ben Cabana’s!

Key Point: If you are looking for a more intimate, budget-friendly island stay with plenty of local charm, then I would recommend staying on Caye Caulker.

A two-story white beachfront house in Ambergris Caye, Belize, surrounded by palm trees and tropical vegetation. The house features balconies and a small patio area with outdoor seating. — Beach front VRBO on Ambergris Caye

Ambergris Caye Accommodations

Ambergris Caye definitely offers a LOT more accommodation options.

Here, you can find everything from budget-friendly hotels to mid-range accommodations and luxury resorts. The island even has a few all-inclusive resorts if that’s your thing.

And there are a lot more Vacation rentals to choose from as well.

🏨 My favorite place I stayed at on Ambergris Caye was this adorable VRBO on a private beach!

Key Point: If you’re looking for more luxurious options or all-inclusive, then I would recommend staying on Ambergris Caye.

For a detailed guide on the best accommodations on these two islands and across Belize, be sure to check out my blog post, “Best Places to Stay in Belize + Your Ultimate Hotel Guide“.

Which has the best beaches

Just a heads up, neither Ambergris Caye nor Caye Caulker have very many beaches. Blame it on the way they were formed and their close proximity to the barrier reef.

But don’t let that stop you!

Both islands have gorgeous coastlines and crystal-clear turquoise waters that are perfect for swimming and all sorts of other water activities.

Kate from Kate's Crossing Blog relaxing in a hammock suspended over the clear turquoise water in Caye Caulker, Belize. She is wearing a sun hat, with sailboats and a thatched-roof pier visible in the background. — Relaxing at Iguana Reef Beach on Caye Caulker

Caye Caulker’s Beaches

Caye Caulker doesn’t have any quintessential beaches, but it does have several small sandy spots along the shoreline, which are all public.

The best options for a beach day here include Iguana Reef, where you can enjoy calm waters, water hammocks, and a small sandy area.

And The Split which is another popular gathering spot for both locals and tourists.

Although Northside Beach Club is currently closed, you can still access its beach for a small fee, providing another nice spot for beachgoers.

Kate from Kate's Crossing Blog floating peacefully in the clear turquoise water off Ambergris Caye, Belize. She is wearing a bikini and enjoying the sunny day, with the shoreline and palm trees visible in the distance. — Swimming at Secret Beach on Ambergris Caye

Ambergris Caye’s Beaches

Ambergris Caye offers a greater variety of sandy beaches compared to Caye Caulker.

The most popular among them is Secret Beach. Despite its name, Secret Beach is no hidden gem. It’s one of the most frequented beaches on the island, known for its stretches of sand and exceptionally calm waters on the leeward side.

Secret Beach is the place to be if you’re after a fun beach day. With its lively beach bars and a ton of water sports activities, it’s an absolute must-visit if you’re craving some fun in the sun.

Keep in mind that a lot of the prime beach spots on Ambergris Caye are tucked away within resort properties. They’re pristine and perfect, but if you’re not booked as a guest, you might need to shell out a few bucks to enjoy them.

The Food Scene

The food scene on Caye Caulker and Ambergris Caye offers a mix of local flavors and international cuisine. Let’s explore the dining options and must-try dishes on each island.

Street food vendors grilling fresh seafood on Caye Caulker, Belize. Lobsters and fish are being cooked on large grills, with a variety of sauces and seasonings in bowls nearby. — Street food is the best food on Caye Caulker!

Caye Caulker’s Food Scene

A unique perk to Caye Caulker and one of my favorite reasons to visit is the street food vendors along the main street. They offer delicious BBQ that’s easy on your wallet. Chef Kareem and his Jerk Chicken is a must-try when you’re there!

If you love seafood, fresh catches are a staple on virtually every menu, celebrating the island’s rich marine life. One of my favorite dishes is the whole fried snapper!

The prices here tend to be more affordable than on Ambergris Caye, making it a great spot indulge without breaking the bank.

Food trucks at The Truck Stop on Ambergris Caye, Belize. The area features colorful containers converted into food stalls, picnic tables, and a bar with stools, all under the shade of trees decorated with lights. — The Truck Stop is a fun place to eat on Ambergris Caye

Ambergris Caye’s Food Scene

On Ambergris Caye, the culinary scene is kicked up a notch with a wider range of dining options.

Here, you can find everything from high-end dining experiences to casual eats, with countless bars to hop in between.

While you won’t find traditional street food, The Truck Stop offers a creative take with its assortment of food trucks, delivering a unique and trendy dining atmosphere.

This variety makes Ambergris Caye a good foodie spot, but expect you’re going to splurge a little more on your meals here.

Cost Comparison

When it comes to costs, Caye Caulker is a more budget-friendly choice between the two, offering more affordable options for accommodations, activities, and dining.

However, the price difference isn’t so stark that it would heavily influence my decision on where to stay.

Both islands provide great value depending on what you’re looking for in a vacation.

A colorful surfboard sign with the text 'Good Tides, Good Vibes' displayed on a dock in Caye Caulker, Belize. In the background, boats and waterfront buildings are visible against the blue sky and ocean.

Ideal Traveler Profile for Each Island

Caye Caulker and Ambergris Caye each attract different types of travelers. Here’s a look at who would enjoy each island the most.

Caye Caulker is Best For

Perfect for travelers who want to save a few bucks and are searching for a quaint, charming escape.

This tiny paradise is ideal if you’re looking to hang out with a younger crowd and soak in a laid-back, authentic Caribbean lifestyle and the “Go Slow” motto.

It’s the perfect spot for those seeking an authentic slice of island life without the commercial buzz.

Ambergris Caye is Best For

Ideal for travelers seeking a more dynamic or resort-style vacation with all the trimmings.

This island is perfect if you want a side of luxury with your getaway, more dining options, and a lively nightlife.

It’s ideal for families, couples, groups of friends, and beach lovers seeking beautiful beaches for sunbathing and relaxation.

Kate walking down a sandy street on Caye Caulker, Belize, holding a cold drink. She is wearing a floral dress, sun hat, and sunglasses, with tropical plants and colorful buildings lining the street. — Between Caye Caulker and Ambergris Caye, Caye caulker is my favorite!

Which Island Would I choose? Ambergris Caye or Caye Caulker?

Personally, my heart belongs to Caye Caulker!

There’s just something about its rustic charm and laid-back “Go Slow” vibe that steals my heart every time.

I love its small, welcoming community where the locals become friends and go above and beyond to take care of you and make sure you’re having an unforgettable time.

Everything is within walking distance, and you’re never far from the awesome activities Belize is famous for. It’s my favorite place to unwind and disconnect from the world.

View from a water taxi between Caye Caulker and Ambergris Caye, Belize. The image shows the vibrant turquoise ocean with small boats and the shoreline of a coastal town in the distance under a clear blue sky. — Taking the water taxi between Caye Caulker and Ambergris Caye

Do You Have to Choose, or Can You See Both?

You definitely don’t have to pick just one!

Caye Caulker and Ambergris Caye are only a short 45-minute water taxi ride apart, making it super easy to enjoy both in a single trip.

If you’re spending a week in Belize, I recommend starting with two days on the lively Ambergris Caye, then winding down with three days embracing the laid-back “Go Slow” lifestyle on Caye Caulker.

That’s exactly what we did on our first trip to Belize. However, once we hopped over to Caye Caulker, we instantly wished we had spent our entire time there—and that’s precisely what we’ve done on subsequent trips.

You can also easily fit in a day trip to one island from the other, giving you a taste of both unique destinations without having to shuffle luggage.

Aerial view of the turquoise waters and small islands of Belize, taken from a plane flying over the Caribbean Sea. The clear blue sky stretches out above the vibrant, shallow waters. — Aerial view of Belize’s Islands

Are These the Only Two Cayes (Islands) You Can Visit in Belize?

Yes and No.

While Caye Caulker and Ambergris Caye are the most popular and accessible, Belize’s turquoise coast is dotted with several other stunning islands.

Several of these smaller islands have luxurious private resorts that are quite pricey but offer an exclusive slice of paradise. In fact, some islands are being artificially created specifically for private resorts.

Belize also has several popular uninhabited cayes that are perfect for day trips and island hopping tours, mostly organized from the Placencia area.

These islands provide pristine natural environments ideal for snorkeling, bird watching, and simply enjoying untouched tropical beauty.

Here are some of the popular uninhabited islands in Belize:

Silk Cayes: Known for their crystal-clear waters and vibrant marine life, making them a top choice for snorkelers and divers.
Laughing Bird Caye: A national park that is a part of the Belize Barrier Reef, offering spectacular snorkeling and diving spots.
Goff’s Caye: A tiny island located right on the edge of the Belize Barrier Reef, popular for cruise ship passengers looking for a quick, idyllic beach stop.
Sapodilla Cayes: Farther south, these Cayes offer a remote and serene escape, with fabulous snorkeling and diving, especially at the renowned Coral Garden.
Tobacco Caye: A small, idyllic spot known for its laid-back atmosphere and excellent opportunities for diving and snorkeling.

Best Resources to Save on Your Belize Island Trip

These are my go-to resources and the first place I check when planning my epic adventures. They consistently provide the best deals, helping you stretch your travel dollar further.

Accommodations 🏨

My favorite accommodation booking sites are Hotels.com and VRBO! You start racking up One Key Cash from the get-go, which you can use for future bookings.

Flights & Car Rentals 🛩️ 🚗

Just a heads up – you can score even more One Key Cash by booking your flights and car rental through Expedia. It all adds up, so you can travel MORE!

Activities and Tours 🏝️

Check out GetYourGuide and Viator for all the best tours and activities. Plus, enjoy the peace of mind that you’ll get a full refund if things go sideways and your plans change.

Travel Insurance 🛄

If you’re thinking about scuba diving, caving, or any other crazy adventure in Belize, seriously, grab some travel insurance. I always use Safety Wing.

Travel Credit Card 💳

Rack up those points to slash your travel costs and tick more adventures off your bucket list! Here’s my favorite travel credit card that’ll help you earn free travel fast!

Packing Guide 🧳

Make sure you don’t forget anything with my complete, finely-tuned Belize Packing List!

A wooden sign on a beach in Caye Caulker, Belize, warning about stingrays coming around the area starting at 4 pm. Another sign below it encourages visitors to 'Enjoy a Drink at The Bar.' People are seen wading in the shallow water nearby. — Sting ray feeding begins at 4 pm on Caye Caulker every night.

FAQ’s: Ambergris Caye vs Caye Caulker

To help you decide between the two, here are some of the most frequently asked questions about visiting Caye Caulker or Ambergris Caye.

What are the main differences between Caye Caulker and Ambergris Caye?

Caye Caulker is smaller, less developed, and has a more laid-back backpacker vibe, making it ideal for budget travelers and those seeking a quieter retreat.

Ambergris Caye is larger and more developed. It offers a lively atmosphere with more dining, nightlife, and accommodation options, suitable for travelers looking for more activity and amenities.

What is the most popular Caye in Belize?

Ambergris Caye is considered the most popular Caye in Belize, attracting the largest number of tourists due to its extensive amenities, vibrant nightlife, and proximity to the Belize Barrier Reef.

Which Belize Caye has the best beaches?

Ambergris Caye has better beaches than Caye Caulker, for sure, but not the best beaches in Belize. Its wider shores and clear waters make it a better choice if you are looking for beaches.

The title for “Best Beaches” doesn’t go to a Caye at all. Placencia on mainland Western Belize is voted to have the best beaches in Belize. Its peninsula gives you an island vibe with water on three sides tho.

Which island is better for budget travelers?

Caye Caulker is a little more budget-friendly, with less expensive accommodation options, more hostels, and a relaxed pace that caters to backpackers and cost-conscious travelers.

Which island offers better nightlife?

Ambergris Caye is known for its vibrant nightlife, which includes a greater variety of bars, clubs, and live music venues. So, if you’re the type who likes the nightlife, Ambergris Caye is your ticket.

Can I visit both Caye Caulker and Ambergris Caye easily?

Yes, it’s easy to visit both islands during the same trip as they are only a short 45-minute boat ride apart. Many travelers choose to split their time between both to experience what each has to offer.

Before you visit Belize’s most popular islands there is a few very important things you should know before you go! Read this post, “21 Must-Know Belize Travel Tips for First-Time Visitors,” next!

Kate enjoying a drink at a waterfront bar on Ambergris Caye, Belize, during sunset. She is seated at a table overlooking the calm sea with thatched-roof picnic tables in the water, reflecting the vibrant colors of the sunset. — Sunset drinks at Secret Beach on Ambergris Caye.

Final Thoughts on Ambergris Caye vs Caye Caulker

Deciding between Caye Caulker and Ambergris Caye feels as clear as mud, right?

Each island has its own cool style and vibe, making them both super appealing in their own unique ways. Caye Caulker brings that chill, laid-back charm, while Ambergris Caye turns up the energy with its lively vibe. It’s a dilemma trying to choose!

But the good news is —you don’t actually have to choose just one!

Since they’re only a 45-minute boat ride apart, why not experience the best of both worlds? You can easily split your time and “double dip” between the two islands.

Whatever you decide, one thing’s for sure: you’re in for an unforgettable adventure. And I have a sneaking suspicion you’ll be back for more.

Talk to ya later!